What types of heating exist?
The following types of heating are most common in New Zealand:
Electric plug-in heaters
They can come in either radiant (e.g. oil column heater) or convection (e.g. bar heater) heat emitting (see above).
Advantages | Disadvantages |
|---|
- Cheap to buy and install
- Instant heat
- 100% efficient i.e. all the energy is converted into heat
- A clean form of heating
- No extra labour (shopping for gas refills, chopping wood etc).
- With a thermostat the temperature can be controlled accurately
- Many have timers
| - More exposure to fluctuating electricity prices
- Fan heaters may create excessive air movement
|
Back to Top
Nightstore heaters
Work with ‘Night-and-Day power plans' and use power at night on the cheaper rate to make heat. The heat is stored in the heater (in bricks) until 7am, when it is released during the day.
Advantages | Disadvantages |
|---|
- Day time warmth at night time prices
- A clean form of heating
| - Considered 80% efficient because sometimes they waste energy by providing heating when it is not required.
- Provides heat during the day only with little heat left for evenings
- They don't emit heat at night
- Higher purchase and installation cost than regular plug-in heaters
- You must decide the night before whether you want heat the next day
|
Back to Top
Woodburners
In many areas and on many properties in the South Island there are now restrictions on whether you can install a woodburner and/or which type of woodburner you are allowed to install.
Advantages | Disadvantages |
|---|
- Can heat a large area
- Cheap to run for those with access to free firewood
- Provide 'atmosphere'
- A wetback can be fitted to heat water (although this reduces the warmth available for space heating and/or uses more wood than conventional woodburner)
- No need for reliable power source (power cuts)
- Some models can be used for cooking
| - Smoke produced pollutes the air
- Extra work stacking, chopping and transporting wood and removing ashes
- It is more difficult to control the heat output of a logburner than a gas or electric heater, which means that you may use more energy than you actually need
- Not instant heat, more work getting it going
- Hard to provide small amount of heat
- Needs a building permit from your local council and sometimes a resource consent from the regional council
|
Back to Top
Pellet fires
A pellet fire looks very much like a woodburner but uses pellets made from compressed sawdust, a sawmill waste product, as fuel. They usually have a fan for ignition and a fan which regulates the oxygen supply.
Advantages | Disadvantages |
|---|
- More energy efficient than logburners
- Burns cleaner than logburners, resulting in better indoor and outdoor air-quality
- Less preparation of fuel and cleaning involved
- Greater control of temperature
- Can still heat a medium/large area effectively
- Has ambience of a 'real' fire
- A wetback can be fitted to some models
| - Requires handling and storage of 20kg pellet bags
- Some clearing (of ashes) involved
- Reliant on a limited number of manufacturers for the fuel source.
- Require electricity to run - emergency generator/battery pack required for emergencies
- Operation produces some noise
|
Back to Top
Heat Pumps
A heat pump is a type of electric heater that coverts electricity into heat in a much more efficient way (up to 4 kW of heat for every kW of electricity) than conventional electric heaters. They have an indoor and outdoor unit.
Advantages | Disadvantages |
|---|
- Clean source of heating.
- Even with a fan, they are considered suitable for most people with asthma as heat pumps filter the air.
- Does not becomes hot
- Easy to operate, requires switching on button only
- Low running cost
- Can be used in reverse as an air conditioner to keep inside air cool in summer but not with the same efficiency as the heatng.
| - Expensive to purchase and install.
- Depending on model, efficiency drops when outside temperature is very low.
|
Back to Top
Diesel Heaters
Advantages | Disadvantages |
|---|
Clean form of heating Some can support a wetback system They give a high heat output Cheaper to run than gas or electricity | Expensive to purchase and install Exposed to variable price of diesel |
Back to Top
Central Heating (Gas/Diesel/Electric)
A central heating device heats water which is transported through pipes to radiators throughout the house.
Advantages | Disadvantages |
|---|
Heats whole house Can provide hot water Heat controlled thermostatically and by a timer Can adjust temperature/ turn off heat in unused area of the house | Very expensive to install Diesel tanks require a permit Fuel access - transported via diesel tanker or in 45kg gas canisters, may be a problem in some areas Ground source heat pumps require a large area of ground to be dug up for pipe installation. |
Back to Top
Flued Gas
Advantages | Disadvantages |
|---|
High heat output Instant heat Clean heat. The level of heat can be controlled more easily than with a log-burner. Don't create dampness and health problems like portable gas heaters. Gas bottle re-fills are paid for up-front rather than getting an electricity bill at the end of the month. | More expensive to install than electric heaters. Cost of the gas bottle rental.
|
Back to Top
Unflued Portable Gas Heaters
Community Energy Action does not recommend unflued portable gas heaters in any circumstance for the following reasons:
- They release up to 1 litre of water into the air per hour of use making your home very damp.
- They work by combustion which draws in oxygen from the surrounding air, and releases water vapour and carbon dioxide into the room. This means they should only be used with adequate ventilation (opening of window) to avoid condensation problems.
- They get less efficient as they get older, which can lead to carbon monoxide (a toxic gas) being released. Carbon monoxide is colourless, odourless, and tasteless. This means unflued gas heaters can only be safely used with adequate ventilation (opening of window) to avoid the risk of carbon monoxide poisoning.
- Using portable gas heaters in bedrooms is extremely dangerous and is strongly discouraged. This is because bedrooms are often small and poorly ventilated. People who are asleep will not be able to respond to any poisoning symptoms.
- The high radiant heat output can be a fire risk if placed close to combustible materials such as curtains, furniture and drying clothes. Clothing of people coming to close could also catch fire.
Unflued portable gas heaters are banned in several countries.
The Gas Regulations require that gas installations are installed in accordance with a set of essential safety requirements (the NZ Gas Installation standard or NZS 5261. It prohibits the installation of (fixed) unflued heaters in bedrooms & bathrooms.
More about heating your home ...
More about the costs of different types of heating systems...
More about insulation...
More about other home energy issues...
If you have any more questions about heating your home, contact our Advice Service.
Back to Top